Jump to content

Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle): Difference between revisions

From Rejoice in the Catholic Faith
Line 56: Line 56:
=== The Trials of Jeanne d'Arc ===
=== The Trials of Jeanne d'Arc ===
> see [https://www.jeanne-darc.info/trials-index/ Trials - Overview | Joan of Arc | Jeanne-darc.info]
> see [https://www.jeanne-darc.info/trials-index/ Trials - Overview | Joan of Arc | Jeanne-darc.info]
== Popular accounts of the life of Joan of Arc ==
=== "The Life of Joan of Arc" by Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel ===
* a children's book first published in 1895
* See entry [[Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle)/The Life of Joan of Arc by Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel|here for more on Boutet de Monvel]] and his American sponsor for his Joan of Arch series of paintings
=== '''"Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc" by Mark Twain''' ===
* Twain's masterful historical-fiction biography of Saint Joan, published in 1896
* See entry [[Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle)/Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc by Mark Twain|here for more on Twain's work on St. Joan]]
*
=== Others ===
"Saint Joan" by George Bernard Shaw
Not much to say about this one. Shaw was early in adulthood an atheist and seems to have wanted into Deism and perhaps belief if not in Christ but in Jesus. The play is considered one of Shaw's greatest works, and it has been repeated on stage through the 2000s and in film. Shaw wrote it after Joan's canonization, thus the title. But he wasn't celebrating it. He tries to humanize Saint Joan, whom he said was romanticized while her accusers were villainized. For Shaw, Joan's tormenters were motivated by the facts and situations before them; you know, it's just a matter of perspective. I can only say that to frame Bishop Cauchon as honestly motivated is akin to Andrew Lloyd Weber's sympathetic portrayal of Judas in ''Jesus Christ Superstar''. Both did wrong, knew it, and did it anyway. And, worse, Shaw portrays Joan as Weber does Jesus, as an anti-establishment pop star. For Shaw, Joan is a rebel against authority, like his female ''ubermensch'' in ''Man and Superman''.  Meh. 


== See also ==
== See also ==

Revision as of 19:54, 3 February 2025


<<to move Translation: she's a witch!





Christology of Saint Joan

  • born in poverty, among shepherds
  • distrust of the leaders
  • triumphant entry to Orleans
  • betrayal
  • Charles VII washing his hands of her
  • championed by her mother

The prophecies of Joan of Arc

Jean Dunois testified that not all of Joan's prophesies were fulfilled[1],

Although Jeanne sometimes spoke in jest of the affairs of war, and although, to encourage the soldiers, she may have foretold events which were not realized, nevertheless, when she spoke seriously of the war, and of her deeds and her mission, she only affirmed earnestly that she was sent to raise the siege of Orleans, and to succour the oppressed people of that town and the neighbouring places, and to conduct the King to Rheims that he might be consecrated (emphasis added)

Prophecies of the coming of Saint Joan

  • Merlin
  • St. Bede
  • Marie d'Avignon

Joan's own testimony on those prophesies

Joan told her Uncle , Durand Laxart, and a woman with whom she stayed on her second visit with him to Vaucouleurs,

“Was it not said that France would be ruined through a woman and afterwards restored by a virgin?”.

>> see Prophecies | Joan of Arc | Jeanne-darc.info

Why Joan only now?

Jeanne d'Arc was canonized in 1905. It's not unusual for such a long delay in beatification, but there are reasons for it with Saint Joan. So why so long for her?

Once her work was done, she was easily forgotten, beginning with the Siege of Orleans and the coronation of Charles VII, upon which the French court did its best to ignore her. Given the opportunity to ransom her upon her capture, the King refused and, well, washed his hands of her. Once they had consolidated rule over France, the kings had every reason -- well, aside from honesty -- not to attribute the legitimacy of their rule to a peasant girl.

>

A rather interesting document is found from a publication, "The Rationalist" from 1913, The Story of Joan of Arc: the Witch Saint,"[2] which seems to have been in response to Pius X's beatification of Joan (final step towards canonization). The author contends that "modern thought" has led to her vindication and not the Catholic Church, which is just using her shrine and stories of miracle cures before it as a "new income." The author says his essay will save Catholicism from itself.

French Revolution

> anticlerical

>

Franco-Prussian War

Historical sources

The history of Joan of Arc is comparatively well-documented, even for the 1400s, a period that yields plenty of artifacts and primary sources. The facts of her life a clear and incontestable. In her day, she was the subject of various documented inquiries, an extended court trial, and subsequent inquiries that document witnesses and assessed evidence. We even know much about her mystical experiences -- or whatever they were, as she told the record about them.

The Trials of Jeanne d'Arc

> see Trials - Overview | Joan of Arc | Jeanne-darc.info

See also

Here for list of pages on this site related to Saint Joan of Arc

Painting series "Jeanne D'Arc" (1895) by Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel

In 1896, Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel illustrated a children's book of the life of Joan of Arc.[3] Through the early 1900s, he expanded several of the images into full paintings, a collection of which are held by the National Gallery of Art in Washington DC, called "La Vie de Jeanne d'Arc":

Here for more on Boutet de Monvel and his works.


References

  1. Murray, p. 241
  2. The Story of Joan Of Arc the Witch--saint, by M. M. Mangasarian
  3. Scan of English version (abbreviated from the original French publication) available here: Joan of Arc : Boutet de Monvel, Louis Maurice, 1850-1913 (Archive.org) Here for page images of the original: Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel