Saint Joan of Arc (Jeanne la Pucelle): Difference between revisions

From Rejoice in the Catholic Faith
No edit summary
Line 20: Line 20:


=== Recollections of Joan of Arc by Mark Twain ===
=== Recollections of Joan of Arc by Mark Twain ===
Few people know that Twain wrote about Joan of Arc. There is a story that as a child he encountered a stray page with the story of her trial, and the young Samuel Clemens took great offense at her interrogators. Whether true or not, he became fascinated by her story and yearned to tell it: <blockquote>I like ''Joan of Arc'' best of all my books; and it is the best; I know it perfectly well. And besides, it furnished me seven times the pleasure afforded me by any of the others; twelve years of preparation, and two years of writing. The others needed no preparation and got none.<ref>[[wikipedia:Personal_Recollections_of_Joan_of_Arc#Writing_process|Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc - Wikipedia]]  No source is given for the quotation, but it is undoubtedly Twain's words.</ref> </blockquote>Modern academics who study Twain consider it unworthy of his canon.<ref>See [[wikipedia:Personal_Recollections_of_Joan_of_Arc#20th-century_critics|Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc - Wikipedia]]</ref> They can't deny that he thought it was his greatest work, and also that it contains classic Twain wit, but they just can't stand that he was "infatuated"  
Few people know that Twain wrote about Joan of Arc. There is a story that as a child he encountered a stray page with the story of her trial, and the young Samuel Clemens took great offense at her interrogators. Whether true or not, he became fascinated by her story and yearned to tell it: <blockquote>I like ''Joan of Arc'' best of all my books; and it is the best; I know it perfectly well. And besides, it furnished me seven times the pleasure afforded me by any of the others; twelve years of preparation, and two years of writing. The others needed no preparation and got none.<ref>[[wikipedia:Personal_Recollections_of_Joan_of_Arc#Writing_process|Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc - Wikipedia]]  No source is given for the quotation, but it is undoubtedly Twain's words.</ref> </blockquote>Modern academics who study Twain consider it unworthy of his canon.<ref>See [[wikipedia:Personal_Recollections_of_Joan_of_Arc#20th-century_critics|Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc - Wikipedia]]</ref> They can't deny that he thought it was his greatest work, and also that it contains classic Twain wit, but they just can't stand that he was "infatuated" with the Maiden of Orleans. 


Those critics complain that in writing the book, Twain succumbed to Catholicism. I have no words to express how stupid that is. It's got to be their animosity for Christianity in general, and for Catholicism in particular, when expressed as profoundly by Saint Joan.  
Some critics complain that in writing the book, Twain succumbed to Catholicism. I have no words to express how stupid that is. It's got to be their animosity for Christianity in general, and for Catholicism in particular, when expressed as profoundly by Saint Joan. Worse, one actually claims that Twain was infatuated by cross-dressing (such as one hilarious scene in Huck Finn and two examples from minor short stories<ref>[https://medium.com/the-awl/the-riddle-of-mark-twains-passion-for-joan-of-arc-8f20f997d13c The Riddle Of Mark Twain’s Passion For Joan Of Arc | by The Awl | The Awl | Medium]</ref>) and his interpretation of the trial of Joan was entirely focused on her male dress. It's even stupider than the accusation of Twain as overly Catholic. 
 
As for Twain's Catholicism, let's just say he falls short. Other than He says next to nothing of the Mother of God, whereas the historical record affirms her devotion repeatedly.<ref>See [https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-137-06954-2_3 The Virgin Mary and the “Voices” of Joan of Arc | SpringerLink]</ref> He mentions but utterly fails to recognize the crucial role of her despair over denial of the Sacrament of the Eucharist in her coerced "abjuration" (not quite an admission, but a kind of renunciation) seven days before her execution. There are other examples, but none detract from Twain's marvelous work. I mention it to show how idiotic it is to criticize Twain for succumbing to either Catholicism or Medieval mysticism. The man loved the story of Joan and dedicated himself to telling it. And not wonder he worked so hard on it: it's not an easy story to tell, and the lines he draws between his fictionalized characters and the true history are fine and never lead away from actual events. It's a grand project.  


A final note: Twain wrote the book before Joan was canonized, thus "Saint Joan" does not appear in the work. Twain does describe her as a saint: <blockquote>She was not solely a saint, an angel, she was a clay-made girl also — as human a girl as any in the world, and full of a human girl's sensitivenesses and tendernesses and delicacies.<ref>citation to do >> p. 369 of 1901 edition (not in Harpers)</ref> </blockquote>
A final note: Twain wrote the book before Joan was canonized, thus "Saint Joan" does not appear in the work. Twain does describe her as a saint: <blockquote>She was not solely a saint, an angel, she was a clay-made girl also — as human a girl as any in the world, and full of a human girl's sensitivenesses and tendernesses and delicacies.<ref>citation to do >> p. 369 of 1901 edition (not in Harpers)</ref> </blockquote>


=== Saint Joan by George Bernard Shaw ===
=== Saint Joan by George Bernard Shaw ===
Not much to say about this one. Shaw was early in adulthood an atheist and seems to have wanted into Deism and perhaps belief if not in Christ but in Jesus. The play is considered one of Shaw's greatest works, and it has been repeated on stage through the 2000s and in film. Shaw wrote it after Joan's canonization, thus the title. But he wasn't celebrating it. He rather sadly tried to humanize Saint Joan, whom he said was overly-romanticized and her accusers villainized. He presents her as a rebel against authority, along the lines of his ubermensch female character in ''Man and Superman''. Shaw presents her tormenters as motivated by the facts and situations before them, and thus, heh, it's all just a matter of perspective.  
Not much to say about this one. Shaw was early in adulthood an atheist and seems to have wanted into Deism and perhaps belief if not in Christ but in Jesus. The play is considered one of Shaw's greatest works, and it has been repeated on stage through the 2000s and in film. Shaw wrote it after Joan's canonization, thus the title. But he wasn't celebrating it. He tries to humanize Saint Joan, whom he said was romanticized while her accusers were villainized. For Shaw, Joan's tormenters were motivated by the facts and situations before them; you know, it's just a matter of perspective. I can only say that to frame Bishop Cauchon as honestly motivated is akin to Andrew Lloyd Weber's sympathetic portrayal of Judas in ''Jesus Christ Superstar''. Both did wrong, knew it, and did it anyway. And, worse, Shaw portrays Joan as Weber does Jesus, as an anti-establishment pop star. For Shaw, Joan is a rebel against authority, like his female ''ubermensch'' in ''Man and Superman''. 


Enough of that.
Be gone.


== Jeanne D'Arc (1895) by Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel ==
== Jeanne D'Arc (1895) by Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel ==

Revision as of 22:28, 5 August 2024

Saint Joan of Arc called herself, Jeanne la Pucelle, meaning "Jean the Maid." Also known as "Joan of Orleans," for her miraculous intervention in the One Hundred Years War, the turning point of which was the "Siege of Orleans," ended by Joan's brilliant military command.

Panthéon - La vie de Jeanne d'Arc (hlw16 0310)- crop folk
Portion of the frieze, "The Life of Joan of Arc," at the Panthéon, Paris.


** page under construction **

The prophecies of Joan of Arc

Liberating Orleans

Freeing the Duke of Orleans

The Crowning of Charles VII

The end of the Hundred Years War

Historical sources

Recollections of Joan of Arc by Mark Twain

Few people know that Twain wrote about Joan of Arc. There is a story that as a child he encountered a stray page with the story of her trial, and the young Samuel Clemens took great offense at her interrogators. Whether true or not, he became fascinated by her story and yearned to tell it:

I like Joan of Arc best of all my books; and it is the best; I know it perfectly well. And besides, it furnished me seven times the pleasure afforded me by any of the others; twelve years of preparation, and two years of writing. The others needed no preparation and got none.[1]

Modern academics who study Twain consider it unworthy of his canon.[2] They can't deny that he thought it was his greatest work, and also that it contains classic Twain wit, but they just can't stand that he was "infatuated" with the Maiden of Orleans.

Some critics complain that in writing the book, Twain succumbed to Catholicism. I have no words to express how stupid that is. It's got to be their animosity for Christianity in general, and for Catholicism in particular, when expressed as profoundly by Saint Joan. Worse, one actually claims that Twain was infatuated by cross-dressing (such as one hilarious scene in Huck Finn and two examples from minor short stories[3]) and his interpretation of the trial of Joan was entirely focused on her male dress. It's even stupider than the accusation of Twain as overly Catholic.

As for Twain's Catholicism, let's just say he falls short. Other than He says next to nothing of the Mother of God, whereas the historical record affirms her devotion repeatedly.[4] He mentions but utterly fails to recognize the crucial role of her despair over denial of the Sacrament of the Eucharist in her coerced "abjuration" (not quite an admission, but a kind of renunciation) seven days before her execution. There are other examples, but none detract from Twain's marvelous work. I mention it to show how idiotic it is to criticize Twain for succumbing to either Catholicism or Medieval mysticism. The man loved the story of Joan and dedicated himself to telling it. And not wonder he worked so hard on it: it's not an easy story to tell, and the lines he draws between his fictionalized characters and the true history are fine and never lead away from actual events. It's a grand project.

A final note: Twain wrote the book before Joan was canonized, thus "Saint Joan" does not appear in the work. Twain does describe her as a saint:

She was not solely a saint, an angel, she was a clay-made girl also — as human a girl as any in the world, and full of a human girl's sensitivenesses and tendernesses and delicacies.[5]

Saint Joan by George Bernard Shaw

Not much to say about this one. Shaw was early in adulthood an atheist and seems to have wanted into Deism and perhaps belief if not in Christ but in Jesus. The play is considered one of Shaw's greatest works, and it has been repeated on stage through the 2000s and in film. Shaw wrote it after Joan's canonization, thus the title. But he wasn't celebrating it. He tries to humanize Saint Joan, whom he said was romanticized while her accusers were villainized. For Shaw, Joan's tormenters were motivated by the facts and situations before them; you know, it's just a matter of perspective. I can only say that to frame Bishop Cauchon as honestly motivated is akin to Andrew Lloyd Weber's sympathetic portrayal of Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar. Both did wrong, knew it, and did it anyway. And, worse, Shaw portrays Joan as Weber does Jesus, as an anti-establishment pop star. For Shaw, Joan is a rebel against authority, like his female ubermensch in Man and Superman.

Be gone.

Jeanne D'Arc (1895) by Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel

In 1896, Louis-Maurice Boutet de Monvel illustrated a children's book of the life of Joan of Arc. Through the early 1900s, he expanded several of the images into full paintings, a collection of which are held by the National Gallery of Art in Washington DC, per here:


Sources

see